Reading the Stella Prize Shortlist – The World Without Us by Mireille Juchau

the-world-without-us-mireille-juchau

Can I start out by saying that I hope I never have to read two books about communes in the space of a few weeks again? Probably not, but I did. It’s just not my scene, man…

And while this hippy commune story – Mireille Juchau’s The World Without Us – compares favourably to the last one I read, I need to stress that two coming-of-age-stories-set-in-communes-with-commune-destroying-fires-and-hippy-mothers-who-can’t-read-plus-a-side-of-paternity-issues on the one prize shortlist is just dumb. Where’s the diversity? Where’s the interest for people* who don’t like hippy commune stories that much?**

There are multiple plots in this story, some of which are heavily interwoven, others which are not. Most of the story is focused on the Müller family – they’re grief-stricken after the loss of their youngest daughter, Pip, to cancer.

“I don’t mean to hurt you, she says. But when I look at your face I see Pip. So I look away. He ought to be shocked. But he’s briefly relieved. It isn’t hate, or some other feeling between them then. It is at least love that averts her.”

In response to Pip’s death, mother Evangeline wanders the forest; father Stefan focuses on his apiary and alcohol; eldest daughter Tess stops speaking; and middle daughter, Meg, channels her worries into intricate drawings. But it is not just a story about grief – there’s the new school teacher struggling to settle in; the discovery of a car wreck and human remains on the Müller farm; disappearing bees; the town loner trying to make sense of his heritage; the town gossip stirring trouble; amnesia, issues of paternity, alcohol abuse, environmental vandalism and much, much more.

It was all a little exhausting… A shame because there were some truly lovely moments in Jachau’s writing.

“Tess sees the bare feet first, whizzing through the air. Then the chopstick shins and saggy knickers, the vulnerable dip where the spine meets elastic. It’s her sister Meg, practising handstands and cartwheels…”

“Her mascara was smudged, a stray pin abseiled from her hair.”

Likewise, if there had been less ‘busyness’, some of the analogies could have been extended – I’m quite sure there was more to be explored in relation to the organisation of bees (hive and commune comparisons and the need to work together); finding one’s voice; and the idea of being foreign (from the introduction of imported queen bees and displaced German-born Stefan and school teacher Jim, to the exploration activities undertaken by a mining company in the surrounding forest).

“…he headed for the lands to find what the Belgian writer*** had so loved in bees: passion for work, perseverance, devotion to the future.”

Further extending the theme of belonging or being foreign, a number of characters (three in total) were questioning their paternity, highlighting the issue of what makes a parent – biology or being present?

I feel like this book could have been so much better with a heavy edit (or perhaps Jachau could have saved some of the plot-lines for her next book?).

Lastly, I must mention the cover. It’s sublime.

3/5 (Just. More like a 2.7)

Will it win the Stella Prize? No.

*me
**and why in God’s name has this situation been repeated for the Miles Franklin? Seriously, judges?
*** The Life of a Bee by Maurice Maeterlinck

Advertisements

13 responses

  1. (Leaving Hope Farm out of it because I still haven’t read it) I am mystified too. Because it is just not in the same league as the other Miles Franklin books.
    And you know, I am getting a bit tired of grief as a theme…

    • I’m also a bit tired of grief as a theme. A look at the Baileys shortlist (I’ve read three of the six) shows that stories don’t have to be all about death to be ‘deep’/ serious/ interesting. I’ll look forward to your thoughts on Hope Farm if you decide to read it.

      • I haven’t explored the Bailey’s Prize. I’ve only got The Green Road on the TBR and will probably read the winner at some stage, but it’s too hard to keep up with everything and at the end of the day, what mostly influences my reading is the reviews I read from bloggers I trust, not nominations for prizes.

  2. Well I’ve managed to read 3 (yes 3) books about communes in the last few months. As well as the 2 you mentioned I also read Arcardia by Lauren Groff after loving Fates & Furies. So I am well and truly communed out :-). Still think nothing comes close to Charlotte Wood’s book, she so deserves the Stella and Miles Franklin.

    • Agree that Charlotte Wood’s book is streets ahead of the others. Oddly, I have another commune book in my TBR stack (Emma Cline’s The Girls) – I requested an ARC months ago because it was getting so much publicity but now, as it comes close to the time when I should be reading it (I think it will be published in June), I’m not feeling the least bit enthused!

  3. Here here to too many books about coming of age in communes with distant/neglectful mothers first menstruation and all. I also read Anchor Point (stella longlist) and again a coming of age rural with remote frustrated mother, overlay of climate change and yep, fire. I really didn’t like “the world without us”, felt it was strngest when in the voice of the teen and overall felt it was like havking my way through the underbrush with a blunt spoon!

    • Haha! *hacking through the underbrush with a blunt spoon* made me laugh! I actually enjoyed quite a few of the individual voices in this book but none of them were given enough space to develop – it all felt like stories were too quickly and conveniently resolved.

  4. Pingback: Stella Prize 2016 – my predictions | booksaremyfavouriteandbest

  5. I haven’t read either book, but found the first one on tuebl.com which has thousands of free books and is legal, fyi. Anyway, I’m a former teenage ‘hippy’ and I’m intrigued. I wonder if I will feel as so many here do, or if my ability to relate, having been there, done that, will give me another POV. Will get back to you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s