Reading the Stella Prize Shortlist – A Few Days in the Country: And Other Stories by Elizabeth Harrower

a-few-days-in-the-country-and-other-stories-elizabeth-harrower

I’m back in familiar-short-story-territory with Elizabeth Harrower’s A Few Days in the Country and Other Stories. And that territory is uneven. Some of the stories in this collection shone but others, not so much. There are twelve stories, predominantly exploring the different roles of women – in friendship, as mothers and daughters, and as wives.

Despite the overarching theme, the collection lacked cohesion. The stories didn’t feel like they belonged together – changes in pace and style jolted me from one to the next. This may be because the stories were drawn from various sources – archives, journals, published and unpublished (written in the 1960s and 1970s) – as opposed to imagined together, written as bedfellows. But here they are together, bound in a striking blue jacket.

My favourite was Alice, a story that is biting and relevant, despite being set in the 1920s. Although the ending is a little introspective, it is satisfying and thoughtful. Equally good was Lance Harper, His Story – the only story told from a male perspective, it had an unexpected twist that ticked all my short-story boxes.

There were others that I enjoyed – The Beautiful Climate was reflective of a time when women had little or no say in the way the family operated and The Cost of Things was weirdly relevant to a discussion I had with someone last night (and I’ll be sending them a few insightful quotes from this story).

In the more successful stories, Harrower quickly established the scene and built the characters. Of Alice’s overbearing mother –

“Her mother was Scottish born and bred – irrational, raucous, bony, quick-tempered, and noisy. She had no feelings. She was bright, like anything burning: a match, a firecracker, a tree. Alice was as watchful as a small herbivorous animal. Mother and child were unsatisfied.”

And in a simple statement, Harrower gets to the root of so many complex mother-daughter relationships –

“Because her mother was her mother, and there was no one else, Alice thought she was marvelous”.

And to the heart of the uneven ‘friendship’, where one women is the ‘banker’ of information* –

“One must start a conversation in some way and, although Miss Frazer’s interest lay more in the rich deep seams of pain, problem, and frustration than in the thin surface soil of mere chatter, she understood the art of mining for such drifts.”

Comparing a writer of Harrower’s calibre to others may be rude but as this book will be compared to the nth degree as part of the Stella Prize judging, I’m going there.  The collection did bring to mind the work of Rose Tremain and Elizabeth Taylor. While I prefer Taylor (who manages to combine the comedy-of-manners with satisfying moral dilemmas) it’s worth noting that you’re likely to enjoy Harrower if Tremain and Taylor are your cup of tea.

2.5/5 Something tells me I’d feel differently about Harrower if I read her novels.

Will it win the Stella? No – it may get a sentimental vote but pitted against Daylight’s short story collection, it comes up short.

*as an aside, I’m glad I’m grown-up enough to avoid these ‘friendships’ like the plague.

Advertisements

3 responses

  1. I’ve just started this book & already feel the Daylight’s short stories are far superior & that I should have raved a little more about them!

    It’s only natural to compare them when your trying to be a shadow Stella judge – we’re all doing it right now 🙂

    I’ve been distracted by Inga Simpson’s latest book this w/e – Where the Trees Were – a 2017 Stella Shortlist possibility surely.

    I can’t but help think that Charlotte Wood has it wrapped up this year.

  2. Pingback: Stella Prize 2016 – my predictions | booksaremyfavouriteandbest

  3. Haha, Kate and Brona, I guess I’m in the minority here. I enjoyed Daylight, but I think Harrower’s writing is out of this world. She leaves me breathless with the depth in which she gets into the psyche of people, and the economy with which she does it. I would love her to have won the Stella, but I wasn’t expecting it. Do try her novel The watch tower. It’s a really powerful book – and probably closest, in this book, to The beautiful climate.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s